Biblical Ethics and Gay Marriage in California
California has been in the news again recently concerning the topic of gay marriage. As I’m sure everyone knows, California passed Prop 8 last fall, a State amendment banning gay marriage, and its passage was widely attributed to a divers coalition of Churches and Christian groups.
For nearly two now weeks Prop 8 has been on trial with both sides arguing over the purpose of marriage. But what I find most interesting is that those bringing the lawsuit opposing it Prop 8 have continually asked witnesses defending the proposition whether or not the legalization of Gay marriage would benefit the spouses and children in gay families. In each case, these witnesses have conceded that it certainly would.
This, I think, is a bit of a coup for the plaintiff.
Also, last week a team of Sociologists from USC published the results of a five-year study and concluded that children raised by same-sex couples on average thrive as well as those of opposite-sex couples and better than single heterosexual parent households. Moreover, they claim the evidence suggests that children raised by same-sex women do the best of all.
There’s a great deal that could be discussed here, including the scientific veracity of the study. That’s very important but this isn’t a science blog and, for now, I’m more interested in another question.
So here it is:
If it can be shown that the legalization of gay marriage positively impacts the physical and emotional well-being of a minority group of men, women, and children then do Christians have a moral and biblical imperative to support it or would you say that, even though a minority group would suffer, that the protection of the traditionally practiced institution of marriage is the best way to support the well-being of everyone in general?
I’m interested in hearing a wide range of Christian perspectives on this, so whether you’re conservative or liberal, gay or straight, please feel welcome to contribute your thoughts. However, fair warning: Comments that I deem to be out of line will be deleted.


Good question.
First I will say that I personally stopped caring a long time ago on whether or not “gay marriage” would become “legalized”. I *think* it was Ron Paul who put it best when he said (and I’m paraphrasing here) that the question wasn’t whether or not gay marriage should be legalized but whether government should be involved with any marriage PERIOD! I actually had a problem with governmental interference with marriage (“legalised” marriage) long before I heard that comment but for some reason couldn’t put it nearly as well as he did. However, I’ll get back to the point of the question.
Although I will say that I’ve heard some good arguments from others about what the Bible MAY have been saying about homosexuality….I will say that I go about this with an open mind and spirit but so far I still do not believe that this lifestyle is within God’s will for anyone’s life.
We all have a free will to choose. Just because we make a choice doesn’t mean it’s the right one but it’s our freedom to make that choice. So quite frankly, whatever choices and lives we lead are between each individual and God. As far as Christians supporting any legislation on this….I guess it would depend on *how* they “support” it and what they feel their convictions are. Even though I’ve stopped concerning myself on whether legislation will pass or not, I still would not be able to support it *spiritually* as I feel it’s not Biblical. Not to mention that although legislation – or *worldy* law – may prove that it’s beneficial for the physical and emotional well-being of the gay community….it’s interesting how it doesn’t mention (or maybe it does) the *spiritual* well being of the minority’s family. At the end of the day – when it’s not healthy spiritually, it’s not healthy for the mind or body either. It would be interesting to know what KIND of studies they did and HOW they conducted them.